How Much Is Your Collection Agency Really Costing You?
Calculate the true cost of agency fees — and see how much you'd save with AI-powered, success-only debt collection.
Calculator
Enter Your Numbers
Total receivables placed with agency
Annual amount sent to collections
Agency recovery rate
Industry average: 11-15%
15%
Agency commission rate
What your agency charges on recovered amounts
30%
With Your Agency
Amount recovered$75,000
Agency keeps$22,500
You receive$52,500
Left unrecovered$425,000
Cost per dollar recovered30¢
With AgentCollect
Estimated recovery$225,000
AgentCollect feeSuccess-only
You receive$191,250
Additional recovered vs agency+$150,000
Your Annual Savings with AgentCollect
$138,750
That's $11,562/month back in your pocket
Visual Comparison
Where Your Money Goes
See how much of each recovered dollar you actually keep.
$52,500
Traditional Agency
$191,250
AgentCollect
Agency fees
You keep (agency)
You keep (AgentCollect)
AgentCollect fee
The Hidden Costs
Why Collection Agencies Cost You More Than You Think
💸
Misaligned Incentives
Agencies are incentivized to collect fast, not protect your brand. They use aggressive tactics that burn customer relationships because their commission is the same whether your customer comes back or not.
📉
Low Recovery Rates
Industry average recovery is just 11-15%. Agencies cherry-pick easy accounts and let the rest expire. With 85%+ of your receivables going unrecovered, the math simply doesn't work in your favor.
⚠️
Hidden Costs Everywhere
Beyond commissions, you're paying with lost customer lifetime value, brand damage from aggressive tactics, and compliance risk. One CFPB complaint can cost more than the entire placement was worth.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
What do collection agencies typically charge?
Most collection agencies charge between 20% and 50% of the amount they recover. The rate depends on the age and size of the debt, with older and smaller accounts commanding higher commissions. Some agencies also charge upfront fees or monthly minimums in addition to their contingency rate.
What's the average recovery rate for collection agencies?
The industry average recovery rate for third-party collection agencies is between 11% and 15% of the total amount placed. This means for every $100 you hand to an agency, they typically recover $11 to $15 — and then take their commission from that amount.
Are success-only fees really cheaper?
Yes, when the recovery rate is significantly higher. A lower fee on a higher recovery amount means you keep more dollars. AgentCollect's AI agents recover substantially more than traditional agencies because they contact every account immediately, follow up persistently, and never take a day off.
What's the ROI of switching from an agency to AI collection?
Most companies see 2-4x more net recovery after switching from a traditional agency to AI-powered collection. The combination of higher recovery rates, lower fees, and preserved customer relationships means you keep significantly more of every dollar owed to you.